connie a.
10/28/2025
It's five stars for a tavern/pub like experience. It does have a lot of character. Lots of wood, there's a good amount of people and yet the noise level is comfy for even group dinners. Our...
Old Mill Tavern
$$
Closed
(165)
Advertisement
Photos
55 State Route 24
Chester, NJ 07930
Old Mill Tavern, located at 55 Route 24 in Chester, NJ, has been a local tradition for over 50 years, offering a welcoming atmosphere for patrons. The tavern specializes in American cuisine and features an impressive selection of 24 beers on tap.
With its rich history and commitment to quality, Old Mill Tavern continues to be a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike. The establishment prides itself on providing a comfortable dining experience that reflects the charm of the Chester community.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5165 reviews
Casey S.
10/21/2025
Stopped by Old Mill Tavern -- a nice little place with a whole lot of heart, just down the road from Alstede Farms. Food: I had the Garlic Buffalo wings and the Buffalo chicken sandwich. The...
Denise D.
5/3/2025
No one noticed us at our table for a solid 10 minutes. Our waitress was slow af. My husband's drink order took another 15 minutes and was wrong. Bacon wrapped scallops were like a D+. My 2 year...
Dee C.
7/26/2025
Sophia was amazing. Very attentive, kind and made one hell of dirty martini. Service was fantastic. Food was exceptional. Great place and would highly recommend.
Harry N.
7/23/2024
Nice people and great ribs! I love the service patches and how old the place is really.
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement