Mike A.
9/22/2025
I'm so glad this little pizzeria is still open and rocking! I ate here 2-3 times a week whilst I worked at Orr's Department store in the Hillcrest Mall late 1980s. Always got a pie when I would...
Nicolosi's Pizza
$
Open
(118)
Advertisement
Photos
755 Memorial Pkwy Ste 205
Phillipsburg, NJ 08865
Nicolosi's Pizza is known for serving some of the most flavorful pizza in the nation. With a commitment to quality, the restaurant offers a unique pizza experience that many customers appreciate. Their dishes are generously topped, often resulting in a rich and savory pizza that can leave patrons reaching for extra napkins.
While Nicolosi's Pizza is praised for its delicious offerings, it has faced criticism regarding its customer service. Some customers have reported that their experiences with staff may not always match the quality of the food. Despite this, the restaurant remains a popular choice for those seeking satisfying pizza.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0118 reviewsPatricia N.
11/7/2025
Back at the Hillcrest mall in Phillipsburg, NJ for that awesome, old style pizza. It's offers simple menu with Neapolitan and Sicilian as the choices, some common toppings plus some basic...
Charles T.
9/23/2024
There are many, many more in the area I need to try still...but Nicolosi's in Phillipsburg is absolutely at the top of my list for Sicilian slice now. They didn't have a pie made so I ordered a...
Colleen R.
7/12/2025
What happened to the best pizza in NW NJ? It was ALWAYS so cheesy. Now it's skimpy. It has been changed for a while now and IDK why. Someone else has been making the pizzas for quite some time....
Mikaela M.
7/7/2025
Disappointed I even bothered to order a pizza; even had to pay an atm fee. What a waste.
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement