Bill M.
1/12/2026
I always gotta hit up a Manhattan Bagel Shop whenever I see one around because I know I'm gonna be able to grab a super solid breakfast sandwich and a killer cup of coffee and this location is an...
Manhattan Bagel
$
Open
(33)
Advertisement
Photos
764 Bloomfield Ave
Caldwell, NJ 07006
Made the Right Way. Every Day. There's a reason our bagels taste different--they're made the traditional way. At Manhattan Bagel, we give each bagel a dip in a kettle of boiling water, then bake them fresh each morning. That's how we get our authentic shiny bagels with a crispy, golden crust on the outside and that soft, satisfying chew inside. No shortcuts. Just real, authentic bagels made the way they were always meant to be. We kettle-boil our bagels to lock in that shine and crunch, then bake them fresh daily for a chewy, golden bite. No shortcuts, just the classic NY method - done right, right here, every day.
Reviews
4.0(33)
Jill R.
10/14/2025
Nice staff and we always love the smoothies. Sandwiches are pretty good too. Great to grab a drink/ smoothie/ sandwich and some spreads or muffins etc on the run. Tables inside too if you have...
Jenny Z.
8/17/2025
I ordered 6 bagels toasted with cream cheese and instead I got cold bagels not toasted and the cream cheese was cold too. Disappointing!
Steve K.
9/26/2019
I regularly go to Manhattan Bagel, and started past few months. Glad I found this small family place. Freshly prepared to order. And if item is warm, then wrapped in aluminum foils to stay warm....
Jennifer M.
2/23/2024
Extremely rude customer service. I had a very simple order consisting of two bagels and a bacon, egg and cheese. The older lady working there today sounded rude from the beginning..and then once...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement