Brewster's Italian Cafe

$$
Open
yelp logo

(513)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

11 W Merchant St
New Buffalo, MI 49117
+1 (269) 946-9300
http://brewstersitaliancafe.com
A locally owned restaurant located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan; Brewster’s New Buffalo puts a contemporary spin on traditional Italian fare, along with creative, globally inspired dishes. While we're rooted in Italian cuisine, our palette expands far beyond the borders of Italy.

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0513 reviews
Photo of Joseph K.
Joseph K.
12/2/2025

This was just about as perfect an experience as it gets. We were in town for a Paul McCartney concert in Chicago and had opted to stay in new Buffalo to have a slightly less expensive room for...

Read more on Yelp
Ines B.
1/4/2026

Cacio e pepe (pasta dish) and The New Yorker (pizza) along with a Cosmo for post dinner Espresso martini... all were FANTASTIC!!!! I always try to stop by here for a little me time and being that...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Selma L.
Selma L.
5/17/2025

Our favorite place to eat when visiting New Buffalo. Our 3 year old liked it so much, he asked to eat here twice on this trip. Their house salad is fresh, big portion size and has a really tasty...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Jill G.
Jill G.
7/27/2025

We absolutely love this place! We were in New Buffalo for a couple days & we ate there for lunch on Thursday & back for breakfast Friday. Beautiful seating area with windows & skylights by the...

Read more on Yelp
Photo of Maralyn O.
Maralyn O.
10/19/2024

The service was great, the food was delicious and didn't break my bank account, but I hate when they nail you for a "convenience fee".... I would rather leave that for the server. Also, a woman...

Read more on Yelp
Owner verified
See a problem?

You might also like

Freddy's Pizza
Fast food restaurants and stands, Eating places, Delicatessen (eating places)

Freddy's Pizza

891
•
$$
"This place is WAY more than just a pizza place! They offer all types of Italian delicacies. Come for the pizza and stay for the Italian Ice or gelato!!"
photo of Jim B.
House of Kobe-Merrillville
Eating places, Japanese restaurant, Sushi bar

House of Kobe-Merrillville

225
•
$$
"WOW! I've been to many hibachi restaurants and cook my own, but this has to rank number one in my book and that means a lot have I've been to several hundred of them. So glad I stopped here...."
photo of Marc H.
Key Pizza
Eating places, Italian restaurant, Caterers

Key Pizza

30
•
$
"i have been a loyal customer for 50 years, i am probably one of the oldest customers here. this place used to be Pizza Go on 169th, then King of Pizza on 169th, then Key Pizza on 169th next to..."
United States›Michigan›New Buffalo›Brewster's Italian Cafe

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.

Advertisement