Christopher A.
10/23/2025
Wow!! I was pleasantly impressed with this place in Louisville! Very simple menu but the burgers and fries were absolutely incredible. The burgers reminded me of in and out in the best way...
Toasty's Tavern
$$
Closed
(289)
Advertisement
Photos
1258 S Shelby St
Louisville, KY 40203
Toasty's Tavern in Louisville, KY, embodies a classy atmosphere where patrons can enjoy a diverse menu featuring appetizers, sandwiches, hot dogs, and vegan and vegetarian options. The tavern also offers a full liquor list and a rotating selection of canned beers, catering to a wide range of tastes.
With a focus on providing a welcoming environment, Toasty's Tavern invites guests to indulge in their culinary offerings while enjoying a relaxed dining experience. The establishment is committed to creating a memorable outing for both locals and visitors alike.
Generated from the website
Find related places
Reviews
4.5289 reviews
Mariah C.
1/10/2026
We went on a Thursday and stood outside on the waitlist. According to the website, Thursday is college night, 25% off with a college ID. We were seated at the bar, the bartender was apologetic...
Claudia E.
12/7/2025
Toasty's feels like such a Louisville Institution™. We were going to see a show with some friends and were trying to decide where to eat beforehand. As soon as someone mentioned Toasty's everyone...
Tom K.
11/20/2025
First visit. Believe the hype. Sat at the bar on a Thursday evening with a friend. Service was stellar. Double smash was fantastic and fries were on point, as well. Burger was very heavy/greasy so...
Donnie S.
12/31/2025
Where do I even start, I have seen so many videos about this place. And wow did it live up to the hype. Service was excellent, food was amazing. One of if not the best smash burgers, I have ever...
See a problem?
In these collections
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement