Bill B.
9/27/2025
The pizza is delicious! They load it up with a lot of meat and veggies if you want. It is covered with plenty of cheese. Kinda hard to eat by hand but so good. And worth it. The service has...
New Bethel Ordinary
$$
Open
(271)
Advertisement
Photos
8838 Southeastern Ave
Indianapolis, IN 46239
New Bethel Ordinary is a restaurant that offers a variety of dining options, including to-go orders for customers on the go. The establishment aims to provide a fulfilling experience with its generous portions and hearty meals. However, some diners have expressed concerns about their service and overall experience.
The restaurant aims to create a welcoming atmosphere for families and friends to enjoy their meals together. Despite past challenges in service during busy times, New Bethel Ordinary continues to serve its community with a focus on delivering satisfying dishes. Guests can expect a diverse menu designed to please a range of tastes.
Generated from the web
Find related places
Reviews
4.0271 reviews
Peter P.
11/17/2025
This place is famous locally for their pizzas and they sure didn't disappoint. They also have a nice selection of bottled beer so it was l worth waiting at the bar for my carryout pizzas to come out.
Tyanna M.
5/30/2025
Ordered the deluxe with a substitution of hamburger for the sausage. Definitely for sausage and after waiting 45 minutes to get it, I ate it. Hate sausage. Hubby had a tenderloin and said it was...
Chaz W.
11/21/2025
It's was okay got the pizza with pepperoni and banana peppers. Super busy so get in or call ahead
Jim A.
11/30/2025
This is an outstanding place to visit. Our crowd of 16 showed up on SAT night to celebrate-we had appetizers, sandwiches, pizza, drinks and a TON OF FUN. The Pizza meets and exceeds the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement