Food

Caplinger's Fresh Catch

$$$

Closed

(52)

Call

Website

Photos

9535 Pendleton Pike

Indianapolis, IN 46236

+1 (317) 389-5378

http://www.caplingersfreshcatch.com

Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market has been a go-to spot in Indianapolis since 2013, offering a wide variety of top-quality fresh seafood that rivals coastal regions. Their daily arrivals are professionally handled in-house, ensuring customers get the tastiest seafood.

At Caplinger’s Fresh Catch, every dish is meticulously prepared with fresh, high-quality ingredients, homemade breading, and sauces. Customers can expect a warm and delightful dining experience, with each meal made to order to cater to their cravings.

Patrons rave about the generous portions and value for money at Caplinger’s, with favorites like Catfish nuggets, lobster rolls, gator bites, and smoked tuna salad. The seafood counter allows customers to take home their fresh selections, including large scallops and a variety of dips and sandwiches that promise a taste of the ocean.

Generated from the website content

Find related places

Restaurants

Reviews

4.052 reviews

Daniel H.

8/17/2025

The Frog Legs and Alligator nuggets are amazing and something I never expected I could get in Indiana. The service was good and they used a buzzer to alert me of my order being done. There isn't...

Read more on Yelp

Laura S.

10/25/2024

This little building is right off pendleton pike just east of post road. Much more convenient for me than going up to 75th and shadeland. It appears to be the same menu the restaurant has for...

Read more on Yelp

Marcus S.

7/25/2025

Let's be for real, food takes time to cook. But I feel like by the time I play a few games on my phone, my food is done. I got the catfish nuggets and they were fire. The greens and Mac and cheese...

Read more on Yelp

Toscha R.

4/9/2025

The catfish filet are always so GOOD ! The service is amazing! I prefer the shadeland location.

Read more on Yelp

Mark B.

8/12/2024

It's definitely a fish market that also sells sandwiches on the side. I ordered a salmon sandwich. It comes all by itself -- no sides. The salmon was good. The market has as much...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

See a problem?

Fish and seafood markets

Caplinger’s Fresh Catch

Caplinger's Fresh Catch, established in 2013 in Indianapolis, IN, offers a diverse selection of high-quality seafood, comparable to that found in coastal regions. Their seafood market ensures that all products arrive daily and are handled with care, guaranteeing freshness for customers. The restaurant at Caplinger's specializes in made-to-order dishes crafted with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces, providing generous portions and exceptional value. Customers can also enjoy a fresh seafood counter, allowing them to take home top-notch seafood for their own cooking adventures. Generated from the website

Fish and seafood markets, Eating places

Fish 'n Wingz

Fish 'n Wingz Cellphone Repair is a local business in Indianapolis, IN that specializes in repairing cellphones and tablets. With a focus on quality service and quick turnaround times, they strive to provide reliable solutions for all types of electronic device issues. Generated from their business information

Fish markets

Post Road Fish Market

Post Road Fish Market is a local seafood market in Indianapolis, IN, offering a variety of fresh fish and seafood options for customers to purchase. They provide a selection of high-quality seafood products sourced from trusted suppliers. With a focus on providing fresh and sustainable seafood, Post Road Fish Market aims to meet the needs of seafood lovers in the Indianapolis area. Customers can expect a range of seafood choices and knowledgeable staff to assist with their selections. Generated from their business information