Alejandro B.
10/30/2025
I went to Gotham New York Bagels and Eat in Chicago and honestly, I loved it. The bagels were super fresh, packed with a ton of filling, and had the perfect texture. I ordered the salmon bagel...
Gotham Bagels - Lakeview
Closed
(140)
Advertisement
Photos
2801 N Lincoln Ave Unit B
Chicago, IL 60657
Gotham Bagels, founded in 2006 by a New Yorker with a vision, aims to bring authentic New York-style bagels to the Midwest. The shop is known for its carefully hand-rolled bagels made from traditional ingredients and inventive sandwiches that combine unique flavor combinations with fresh ingredients.
With a commitment to quality and an extensive menu, Gotham Bagels serves as a go-to destination for bagel lovers in the Chicago and Madison areas. Their catering options are perfect for any occasion, ensuring that customers can enjoy their delicious offerings wherever they are.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0140 reviews
Ernie H.
11/9/2025
I'm back, same chill staff and GM(skinny guy with the baseball cap). A little dirty on the floors but I'm not complaining. The cinnamon pumpernickel sugar is perfectly sweetened meaning not...
Brooke L.
12/20/2025
This location can be hit or miss. Sometimes the bagel is not toasted or they forget to add a pickle. The staff are always really friendly but sometimes I think that they just can't keep up with...
Shannon W.
12/22/2025
The price is just completely unjustifiable. If you're gonna charge $15 for a breakfast sandwich it better be the best breakfast sandwich I've ever had in my life. I ordered an egg bagel sandwich...
Stephanie L.
10/6/2025
Not bad! This bagel is a proper meal! I was full until dinner! My only food complaint is the spicy ketchup that came on the Rocky was a bit overwhelming. I wish I would've gotten it on the side so...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement