Mike D.
11/29/2025
Great dough! Good NY pizza. Really enjoyed the pizza. Friendly team and good service for take out only. Try it! Former New Yorker
New York Pizza Company
Closed
(5)
Advertisement
Photos
18406 E Colonial Dr
Orlando, FL 32820
New York Pizza Company, located inside a Mobil Gas Station in Orlando, FL, proudly serves the East Orlando area, including Chuluota, Bithlo, Wedgefield, and Christmas. Known for their authentic New York-style pizzas, they offer a diverse menu that includes delectable subs, flavorful wings, and mouthwatering calzones.
Committed to catering to all diets, New York Pizza Company provides gluten-free options, vegetarian choices, and halal-certified menu items. Their dedication to using the freshest ingredients ensures a delicious dining experience for every guest.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
5.05 reviews
Joe S.
11/21/2024
This is probably some of the best pizza this side of Orlando... East that is! I ordered via Uber Eats and it arrived quickly and was nice and hot thanks to the Uber driver being prepared with one...
Jennifer S.
10/5/2024
Pretty stoked for another pizza option that is deliverable to Wedgefield! My first time ordering at New York pizza company today, which I did pick up on my way home, it was ready in almost the...
A J.
11/7/2024
East Orlando, FL - Needed something quick in the area. Grabbed a stuffed slice and ham & cheese pinwheel. I was pleasantly surprised. Delicious! The marinara sauce that came with it was tasty...
Mandee B.
3/9/2025
OMG! This place is fantastic!! I have no idea how or why they are hiding at the back of a gas station (the SE corner at E.Colonial/Bithlo), but I sure am glad I took the risk! Best NY pizza I have...
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement