Christopher B.
11/6/2025
As an Italian from NYC, I'm picky about pizza and NY NY Pizza blew me away. After 14 years in Florida, this is hands-down the best NYC style Neapolitan pizza I've had here. The cheese pizza was...
New York New York Pizza
$$
Open
(125)
Advertisement
Photos
11203 Sheldon Rd
Tampa, FL 33626
New York New York Pizza in Tampa, FL, offers a taste of authentic New York-style pizza to locals and visitors alike. With multiple locations across the Tampa Bay area, including Carrollwood, Hyde Park, and Ybor City, patrons can enjoy a slice of the Big Apple without leaving Florida.
Known for their mouthwatering menu featuring a variety of pizzas, calzones, and other Italian specialties, New York New York Pizza aims to bring a slice of New York City's culinary scene to the Sunshine State. Whether dining in or ordering for takeout or delivery, customers can savor the flavors of classic New York pizza right in Tampa.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.5125 reviews
Charlie G.
4/7/2025
Sausage and Pepperoni Stromboli. It was ok... pretty light on the cheese and meat, and not much of a flavor punch.
Aaliyah J.
5/24/2025
First off, this is my first time coming to this NYNY location, I've had other locations and they're my favorite chain for NY style pizza in Tampa. I'd say this location is not the best NYNY...
Jennifer H.
2/2/2025
I was shocked at how quickly this pizza was delivered to my door! Delivery Man was very pleasant too. Absolutely delicious!! The cheese was still sliding off of this piping hot, crunchy crust. I...
James B.
7/9/2025
This pizza used to be good, not any more. First, let's call a large pizza an extra large so it gives the illusion you're getting more when you're really not. Over $21 for an "xl" cheese pizza. The...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Advertisement