Five Star Pizza - Sarasota

Our server at Gilligan's last night recommended we order our pizza for the IU vs OSU game from Five Star Pizza. I read the reviews and they were not the most favorable. Sadly, I am not sure what...

I moved to Sarasota from Bradenton. 5 star pizza is 5 stars in Bradenton but NOT SARASOTA. The cashier front desk person was rude and there's barely any toppings on our small pizza. Highly...

Average pizza at best. Service was confusing. Late hours only real benefit. Much better options in the area

Just picked up a plain 18" pizza. Looks terrible. Top is burnt. Seriously disappointed.

Absolutely awful. Our fatass delivery driver kept our pizza in his car and insisted that we did not pay for it, even though I had my receipt from the restaurant in hand. Absolutely ridiculous. The...