Conch Custard

$
Closed
yelp logo

(96)

Call
Website

Advertisement

Photos

11524 Overseas Hwy Ste 4
Marathon, FL 33050
Homemade Premium Scoop Ice Cream and Italian Water Ice. Also Serving Premium Soft Serve Custard, Milk Shakes, Malts, Floats & Gelatis.

Reviews

yelp logo
5.096 reviews
Photo of Kaitlyn M.
Kaitlyn M.
12/9/2025

Excellent soft serve, coconut ice cream was AMAZING. On the sweeter side but delicious coconut flavor. Butter pecan was not my favorite. It was overly sweet and had a slight artificial flavor, in...

Capi S.
12/13/2025

Yummy!! So good and fresh. Service was excellent-offered tastings so we could decide. Fun cutie decor and clean. So many choices too- our part of 6 all found something special.

Photo of Dave T.
Dave T.
6/7/2025

This is a must visit if in or passing thru marathon key. We both had the Italian ice and vanilla custards large $7.49 each. The gentleman behind the counter quickly whipped up our order, one with...

Photo of Jen K.
Jen K.
8/5/2025

Great homemade delicious ice cream. Pints are underrated and really worthwhile. Also underrated is the gelati (the froyo + icy is a yum combo - but hard to pick over the ice cream). Terrific...

Photo of Mary K.
Mary K.
6/1/2025

Great service from some really nice young women that work there. Ice cream is amazing and of the best quality. Hard to choose flavors because they all looked delicious. I had the key lime and...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesFloridaMarathonConch Custard

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Advertisement