M F.
12/24/2025
Tucked away upstairs on the main drag, Captiva Island Pizza is one of those hidden gems that's easy to miss--but absolutely worth finding. The shop is small and has limited/no indoor seating, so...
Captiva Island Pizza
$$
Closed
(92)
Advertisement
Photos
11513 Andy Rosse Ln SW
Captiva, FL 33924
Captiva Island Pizza is a charming eatery located on the second floor of a three-story pink building in Captiva Village. Known for its custom pizzas, the restaurant invites guests to take their delicious creations to enjoy at nearby accommodations or on the beach at sunset.
In addition to their flavorful pizzas, patrons can indulge in a delightful Key Lime Pie available for take-out. As the first restaurant on the island to reopen following Hurricane Ian, Captiva Island Pizza appreciates the community's support during its recovery.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.592 reviews
Rob N.
12/14/2024
Everything great. I have a lot of pizza in my life, NY style, Chicago style and all things in between. We arrived hungry and needed a quick meal, so we chose pizza. Seriously good pie. This pic...
Mike C.
12/24/2025
We enjoy their Pizza on most of our visits. Unfortunately they are not open today. We will try again on another visit. In the mean time we'll go to Tween Waters and try their pizza.
Vanesa C.
11/15/2025
Amazing pizza! The taste. Everything. I'm from out of town. This was the first restaurant that popped out. Glad we went.
Chris C.
12/13/2025
Good pizza. I was really impressed by the detail in service and hospitality. Would recommend getting the cheesy bread.
See a problem?
You might also like
Advertisement