Pennywise Consignment Shop

32 reviews

+1 (860) 572-9232

Website

Photos

Rebecca Minkoff shoes on sale for $28!!!

22 Greenmanville Ave

Mystic, CT 06355

+1 (860) 572-9232

http://www.pennywisemystic.com

Adult clothing and accessories, new and consigned. Open 7 days. MC/VISA, Discover, debit cards and Apple Pay accepted. Across from Mystic Seaport.

Reviews

4.032 reviews

Adam D.

1/27/2025

This place is great - I have been to Pennywise many times as a consignor and shopper. The 50/50 split is more than fair to not have the hassle of selling leftover name brand clothes on eBay or...

Read more on Yelp

Alejandra P.

1/18/2025

Came here exploring Mystic and found one thing I liked but it was extremely overpriced for a used consignment store. Some items are new but some are used and can definitely be dropped down in...

Read more on Yelp

C S.

4/25/2025

I have been a regular customer of Pennywise for 30 years now and I continue to find things I love. Their selection and quality of items has only increased over the years, and prices reflect that....

Read more on Yelp

Tiffanie S.

7/30/2024

Love this store! Very neatly organized with something for everyone. Excellent handbag and Lilly Pulitzer collection. Hit them up when they have a sale, $3 for a basically brand new summer top!...

Read more on Yelp

K H.

2/29/2024

My all time favourite consignment shoppe! Donna is a wonderful business owner and person. I love that this place is family owned and family run. They curate the shoppe beautifully and tend to...

Read more on Yelp

Own this business?

Claim it

See a problem?

Women's specialty clothing stores, Office furniture and store fixtures, secondhand

Plato's Closet

"This store has a really great selection of clothing that isn't outdated compared to the Wethersfield & Manchester's locations that I have also been to that always have a crummy selection. So it..."