Robin F.
9/5/2025
Absolutely delicious! And I even got a frozen pot pie to go! Good service and thoughtful people. Great salads and iced tea, too.
The American Pie Company
$$
Closed
(270)
Advertisement
Photos
29 Route 37 Ctr
Sherman, CT 06784
Delicious sandwiches,breakfast and brunch,lunch and dinner. Tempting baked goods.Signature chicken pot pie. Pizza too!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0270 reviews
Rob M.
10/31/2024
American Pie Company offers an exceptional diner experience. And do not miss out on the bevy of delicious baked goods in front! We saw no need to over complicate things. The Chicken Pot Pie, the...
Jane D.
12/2/2024
Hmm. Something happened to American Pie Company. Something good. We just tried the cottage pie again after a few years' hiatus. This time, it was made with real potatoes -- real red-skinned...
Paula B.
12/10/2025
Excellent food and service. Beautiful small town in CT! Took home delicious baked goods, enjoyed the chicken pot pie and blueberry pie for lunch as well as hot apple cider!
Gina W.
7/13/2024
Cute breakfast spot that serves up big plates and hospitality! Came for breakfast Friday morning and as you enter through the bakery side, you can see all their pies, cookies and cupcakes. The...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2026. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement