Keahi E.
3/21/2025
A friend that's lived in Fort Collins their entire life and grew up near Gib's took me to this place for the first time and I really enjoyed it. You can feel the deep community roots and the...
Gib's New York Bagels
$
Closed
(98)
Advertisement
Photos
2531 S Shields St Ste 2E
Fort Collins, CO 80526
Founded in 1994, Gib s NY Bagels is a chain of retail stores. Its stores deliver products throughout Colorado and Wyoming. The chain s stores offer box lunches, sweets, sandwich and bagel platters, and meat, cheese and vegetable trays. Gib s NY Bagels also provides catering services for various social and corporate events of up to 100 people. In addition, it offers donations and charity grants to various organizations, such as the CSU Athletic Department, Boys and Girls Club of Larimer County, 9 Health Cares, Food Bank for Larimer County and Project Self Sufficiency. It maintains a presence in Fort Collins, Colo.
Also at this address
Find related places
Reviews
3.098 reviews
Ramesh N.
11/17/2025
The staff is very rude and condescending, treats people of color and neurodivergent like we are aliens. A bunch of spoiled entitled college kids with no more abilities than to make bagels. Got...
Brent B.
5/3/2025
Clearly a local place with some history behind it. Reasonably priced for the portions, though quality is just okay. Bagels are hard to make, though, so I'm sure I'll be back still.
Michelle F.
10/22/2025
15 min wait for soup! Just scoop it out at order time! Then forgot bread. Then the bread was cold. Cold bread. Yuck.
Olivia C.
7/28/2025
Don't go here if you're having a bad day, they'll make your day even worse. Not to mention the bagels are actually terrible and not NY style at all. Their online ordering system is also messed...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.
Advertisement